There seems to be a large segment of a particular political party that enjoys employing a series of what they consider cleaver phrases to the point where those phrases become nothing more than cliché` and overly tired arguments. “Stay the Course,” “Mission Accomplished,” and most recently, “Blame America first crowd” have all surpassed the status of cleaver phrase and crossed over to the realm of tired, hollow arguments against those who disagree with the current deployment of our troops in Iraq.
“Blame America first” is an interesting non-argument because it provides greater understanding and perhaps a bit of sympathy to those who are against any plan to withdraw from Iraq either strategically or otherwise. It is also an interesting catchphrase because despite it’s vagueness, its initial message is not difficult to understand.
It can best be described as a reactionary phrase. It is a reaction to the frustration of the realization that the United States is very likely responsible for the mess in Iraq. It is made in denial of that fact, but its not necessarily made in attempt to mislead those who are unaware of the facts in Iraq. It is a common form of denial, similar to the denial of the death of a loved one. This form of denial is one of the stages of dealing with a loss, and we as a nation are certainly dealing with loss. We have lost many loved troops abroad. The world has lost many loved citizens who were unjustly and unfortunately caught in the crossfire, both literal and figurative, of this war. We as a nation are dealing with our loss of credibility and our loss of faith in a leader whom we feel we should be able to place more trust in.
Unfortunately, denial in this case has increased the degree of polarization between those who are pro-war and those who are anti-war. This initial stage of dealing with loss is detrimental to society yet necessary for those who are coming to terms with the fact that the United States is waging an illegal war against Iraq, and that the United States is committing the same sorts of atrocities in Iraq that it has sworn to protect against.
This stage of denial, however, also beckons the potential for hope. If enough those who are in denial about the truths of the Iraq war proceed through the stages of loss quickly enough, their shift in perspective on the war will hopefully contribute to the positive resolution in Iraq and the decrease in polarization among the citizens of the United States. This does not require a shift of political parties to accomplish. Rather, it requires the recognition of injustice and the desire to rectify those injustices. Instead of an area of policy that causes divisions between members of political parties, the war in Iraq can easily turn to greater unification of political parties on the grounds that atrocities against humanity should be rectified. Already we are beginning to see Republican and Democratic Senators unifying on this position as house and senate members push to end the war on Iraq .
Hopefully, the era of political unification on this important issue is near. Until then, it is important that those against the war in Iraq not be too critical of those who are partaking in the “blame America first” argument. Instead of being relentless in argument, calmly state your position, refuse to get frustrated at any non-argument they provide against you, and be prepared to assist with the grieving process they are likely undergoing.
Showing posts with label Foreign Policy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Foreign Policy. Show all posts
Monday, April 02, 2007
Saturday, December 02, 2006
Change the Course
Withdrawal from Iraq is becoming less of a partisan issue and more of a general consensus among politicians. The bipartisan Iraq Study group has recently released a preliminary conclusion of its study which calls for the gradual withdrawal of all United States combatants by 2008, leaving soldiers to train Iraqi military and security forces in order for them to take a more active role in ending secratarian violence.
Noted former secretary of defense Henery Kissinger has declared that the objectives and the definition of victory in Iraq needs to be changed, stating that a military victory in Iraq is no longer possible. As quoted by CNN:
It seems as if the only prominent decision maker in foreign policy is the only one who holds the position that "Staying the Course" is a good idea. Unfortunately, he is also the supreme authority in regards to making foreign policy. In response to the Iraq Study group, Bush declared that a strategy concerning exit in Iraq "has no realism to it whatsoever."
Before proposing further comment regarding the issue, it is important to note that Bush aides infered that the President is not completely resistant to change in policy concerning Iraq, saying that there are options that "he's (the President) is very open to."
It is interesting, however, that the President is not considering the advice of those who have extensive credibility regarding foreign policy towards Iraq, especially that of Donald Rumsfeld (who was allegedly asked to resign because his perceived strict advocation of "stay the course"). It seems as if the President has an unrealistic vision he wishes to pursue in Iraq. His rejection of the Iraq Study Groups findings is epecially alarming considering the report has yet to be released.
The president needs to realize that his objectives in Iraq are unrealistic. At minimum, he needs to heed the advice of Rumsfeld and Kissinger that policy change is needed in Iraq. He should carefully consider the consensus reached by the Iraq study group and delay making any prejudgeces in regards to the conclusions reached by the report until he has the opportunity to read the full report.
Noted former secretary of defense Henery Kissinger has declared that the objectives and the definition of victory in Iraq needs to be changed, stating that a military victory in Iraq is no longer possible. As quoted by CNN:
"If you mean by clear military victory an Iraqi government that can be established and whose writ runs across the whole country, that gets the civil war under control and sectarian violence under control in a time period that the political processes of the democracies will support, I don't believe that is possible."Even Donald Rumsfeld, recently resigned from his position as Secretary of Defense, sees a need for a change in the President's foreign policy in Iraq. "In my view it is time for a major adjustment," he wrote in a memo to the white house. "Clearly, what U.S. forces are currently doing in Iraq is not working well enough or fast enough." (NYTimes, December 2nd).
It seems as if the only prominent decision maker in foreign policy is the only one who holds the position that "Staying the Course" is a good idea. Unfortunately, he is also the supreme authority in regards to making foreign policy. In response to the Iraq Study group, Bush declared that a strategy concerning exit in Iraq "has no realism to it whatsoever."
Before proposing further comment regarding the issue, it is important to note that Bush aides infered that the President is not completely resistant to change in policy concerning Iraq, saying that there are options that "he's (the President) is very open to."
It is interesting, however, that the President is not considering the advice of those who have extensive credibility regarding foreign policy towards Iraq, especially that of Donald Rumsfeld (who was allegedly asked to resign because his perceived strict advocation of "stay the course"). It seems as if the President has an unrealistic vision he wishes to pursue in Iraq. His rejection of the Iraq Study Groups findings is epecially alarming considering the report has yet to be released.
The president needs to realize that his objectives in Iraq are unrealistic. At minimum, he needs to heed the advice of Rumsfeld and Kissinger that policy change is needed in Iraq. He should carefully consider the consensus reached by the Iraq study group and delay making any prejudgeces in regards to the conclusions reached by the report until he has the opportunity to read the full report.
Sunday, October 15, 2006
North Korean Logistics
There have been many who consider North Korean dictator Kim Jong Ill to be an irrational dictator, calling his isolationism foreign policy as self destructive to his country. They use this rationale to advocate their belief that North Korea's possession of a nuclear weapon is threatening to the international community, demanding sanctions be placed . Some have gone so far as to call for the United States to respond militarily.
The assertion that Jong-Il is insane is incorrect. Jong-Il has made the same realization that his father, Kim Il-sung, made, which is that the most effective way to consolidate power in a state is to have complete control over the population. This involves the limiting of foreign influence, which calls for the abolition of any foreign media, as well as the strict regulation of or termination of domestic media (which resulted in only two television channels available in North Korea, both of which are owned and operated by the state).
Jong-Il's desire for a nuclear weapon is actually the behavior of a rational leader. Jong-Il, along with other nuclear weapon seekers such as Iran's Ali Khamenei, realize that never in the history of international relations has a country with a nuclear weapon been invaded. In the interest of maintaining power and hopes to eliminate any foreign threat, Jong-Il has publicized his alleged possession of nuclear weapons technology.
The plausibility of Il's claim that his country has the ability to produce nuclear weapons is substantial enough to attract the attention of the international community. Already, the UN security council has condemned the actions of North Korea, and most are calling for sanctions against the country. China, however, has been the most reluctant country to cooperate, rejecting the United State's demand that they cut off all trade relations with North Korea. They have however, agreed to comply with the UN's request of discontinuing the trade of military goods with North Korea.
The United States will likely never see a war between themselves and North Korea. Each country understands the ramifications of such a war, which would be significant for both countries. Instead, the United States and the United Nations must rely on diplomacy to effectively contain any threat by North Korea. Additional pressure by China is essential in the continuation of successfull diplomacy. Because of North Korea's reliance on Chinese trading, any threat to eliminate trade with North Korea will have significant leverage on Jong-Il's decisions regarding his nuclear program.
The assertion that Jong-Il is insane is incorrect. Jong-Il has made the same realization that his father, Kim Il-sung, made, which is that the most effective way to consolidate power in a state is to have complete control over the population. This involves the limiting of foreign influence, which calls for the abolition of any foreign media, as well as the strict regulation of or termination of domestic media (which resulted in only two television channels available in North Korea, both of which are owned and operated by the state).
Jong-Il's desire for a nuclear weapon is actually the behavior of a rational leader. Jong-Il, along with other nuclear weapon seekers such as Iran's Ali Khamenei, realize that never in the history of international relations has a country with a nuclear weapon been invaded. In the interest of maintaining power and hopes to eliminate any foreign threat, Jong-Il has publicized his alleged possession of nuclear weapons technology.
The plausibility of Il's claim that his country has the ability to produce nuclear weapons is substantial enough to attract the attention of the international community. Already, the UN security council has condemned the actions of North Korea, and most are calling for sanctions against the country. China, however, has been the most reluctant country to cooperate, rejecting the United State's demand that they cut off all trade relations with North Korea. They have however, agreed to comply with the UN's request of discontinuing the trade of military goods with North Korea.
The United States will likely never see a war between themselves and North Korea. Each country understands the ramifications of such a war, which would be significant for both countries. Instead, the United States and the United Nations must rely on diplomacy to effectively contain any threat by North Korea. Additional pressure by China is essential in the continuation of successfull diplomacy. Because of North Korea's reliance on Chinese trading, any threat to eliminate trade with North Korea will have significant leverage on Jong-Il's decisions regarding his nuclear program.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)